Ariana, Thanksgiving, and Early Thanksgiving – Mini Shrimp Salad Rolls

It’s a well-known fact in our family that my daughter Ariana hates Thanksgiving. Her birthday butts up against the holiday every year getting in the way of her personal celebration, and she dislikes the food. Dry turkey, mushy mashed potatoes, cooked string beans have never been her thing. The only reason she even comes to our Early Thanksgiving is for the appetizers.

However, in the fall of 2023 she had one of her best Thanksgivings. But it didn’t start out that way…

At the time, Ariana had recently graduated from college. After a summer in Berlin, she moved back home for a few months to work and save money. We weren’t planning to have a big Thanksgiving celebration, but we would certainly have a nice family dinner. Our son Jacob would come home with his girlfriend (now wife) Amy, and we would switch out the Thanksgiving meal, opting for steak in its place. We often skip the traditional dishes since I already cook a turkey and all its accompaniments for our annual Early Thanksgiving and to make Ari happy around her birthday. But that year it was not to be.

In mid-November, my wife Marci and I took a lovely trip to Scotland. On the way home, the woman sitting next to me on the airplane was sniffling and sneezing. A few days later I experienced my first COVID symptoms. I sequestered myself in an empty room so as not to infect the others. But a day or two later, Marci got sick. There was nothing we could do. We avoided Ariana entirely; no need for her to catch the virus. As Ari’s birthday and Thanksgiving approached, we felt no better and still tested positive.

Jacob and Amy made alternative plans, shunning us entirely, but Ariana was stuck; we would not be sharing a family meal with her, and she was likely to spend her birthday – the day before Thanksgiving – alone. The weather was terrible, cold and raining. She was miserable, but there was nothing we could do.

Fortunately, there was another plan in the works, of which she was unaware. Unbeknownst to Ariana, her two friends from college – Alec and Lyla – who hail from Los Angeles, were going to be on the east coast. Their siblings live in New York City, and they were coming to join them for the festive day. Together we secretly developed a plan.

We told Ariana that some of our friends felt sorry for us since we were sick and were going to drop off some food. She would have to answer the door and accept the packages since she was not ill and contagious.

When the doorbell rang and she went to answer it, Marci and I crouched on the steps of the second floor looking down, a safe distance away. She was grouchy and complaining. But when the door opened, there were Alec and Lyla standing in the rain. She squealed with delight. Without any hesitation she put on her coat, and they left the premises to enjoy a night out with breathable, unpolluted air. The next day, she left with them for the Hudson Valley for their celebration. Even though it was Thanksgiving, she was overjoyed. She got to spend it not with her snotty coughing parents locked upstairs in their bedroom, but cooking and eating with her friends.

It was one of her best Thanksgivings ever.

Ariana did join us and friends for this year’s Early Thanksgiving where she ate an abundance of appetizers, but only a meager few bites of the main meal.

 

Here is this year’s Early Thanksgiving Meal:

 

Appetizers:

 

Mini Shrimp Salad Rolls – recipe below

mini shrimp salad rolls
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Prosciutto-Wrapped Asparagus

prosciutto-wrapped asparagus
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Ricotta and Sage Fried Meatballs

ricotta and sage fried meatballs
Copyright © Ariana Strieb 2026

 

Butternut Squash Tart with Fried Sage

butternut squash tart with fried sage
Copyright © Ariana Strieb 2026

 

Hot Cheese Olives

hot cheese olives
Copyright © Ariana Strieb 2026

 

Crudités

crudites
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Feta, Walnut, and Olive Oil “Dip”

feta walnut olive oil dip
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Spiced Candied Pecans

spiced glazed pecans
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Roasted Tomatillo Salsa and Chipotle Salsa with Tortilla Chips

chipotle and roasted tomatillo salsas
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

 

Main Meal:

 

Roasted Turkey

Porcini Mushroom Gravy

Mashed Potatoes

Corn Pudding

Butter Simmered Carrots

Garlic Green Beans

Cranberry Chutney

thanksgiving dinner
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

Desserts (brought by guests):

 

Orange Chocolate Brownie Torte

Flourless Chocolate Cake with Raspberries

Crunt Cake (Chocolate Crumb Bundt)

Carrot Cake

Apple Pie

desserts
Copyright © Max Strieb 2026

 

 

Mini Shrimp Salad Rolls

Similar to lobster rolls but far more accessible, less expensive, and easier to prepare, these mini shrimp salad rolls can make for a full meal, be part of a small plates menu, or be served as an appetizer as I did at our recent Early Thanksgiving.

 

makes about 36 mini shrimp salad rolls, about 30 minutes plus cooling time

 

2 lemons, divided

2 Tbsp. plus ¼ tsp. salt, divided

2 bay leaves

about 20 black peppercorns

2 lbs. deveined, shell on shrimp, defrosted in the refrigerator if frozen

3 Tbsp. mayonnaise, or more to taste

1½ tsp. Dijon mustard

¼ tsp. fresh ground black pepper

1 Tbsp. fresh tarragon, minced

1 Tbsp. fresh chives, minced, plus more for garnish

½ stalk celery, finely chopped, optional

4 Tbsp. (½ stick) butter

36 (3 packs) Martin’s Sweet Party Potato Rolls (the smallest ones), or other hot dog or dinner rolls

 

  1. Fill a 5 or 6-quart pot with water, leaving enough room to comfortably fit all the shrimp. Cut one lemon in half and squeeze the juice into the pot. Add the squeezed lemon to the pot, along with two tablespoons of salt, bay leaves, and black peppercorns. Bring to a boil, reduce heat, and simmer for 15 minutes.
  2. Prepare an ice bath by placing a few cups of ice and a cup or two of cold water in a large bowl.
  3. Add the shrimp to the pot and cook until pink and just done, about two to five minutes, depending on size.
  4. Drain the shrimp, place in the ice bath, and allow to cool completely for about 10 minutes.
  5. While the shrimp are cooling combine mayonnaise, mustard, pepper, fresh tarragon, fresh chives, celery (if using), juice of half a lemon, and remaining ¼ teaspoon of salt in a small bowl.
  6. Peel the shrimp, dice into ¼ to ½-inch size pieces, and place in a large bowl.
  7. Stir most of the mayonnaise mixture into the shrimp. Taste and add the remainder if needed. Add more mayonnaise, spices, or lemon juice to shrimp salad if desired.
  8. Melt 2 tablespoons of butter over medium heat in a large skillet. Place as many rolls as will fit in pan in melted butter and cook until the bottoms are golden brown. Remove to a platter and repeat with additional butter and remaining rolls.
  9. Make one ½ to 1-inch slice along the top of each roll, making sure not to slice all the way to the bottom. Divide shrimp salad equally among all rolls and arrange on a platter. Top with additional minced chives if desired.

 

 

 

Please like and share this post:


1 thought on “Ariana, Thanksgiving, and Early Thanksgiving – Mini Shrimp Salad Rolls”

  • Max – did anyone eat the main meal after all those beautiful appetizers? I’ll have to attend one of these years and find out for myself!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *